dota imba legends v2.0.w3x main criterion for granting commit access is good judgement, then why assume someone’s judgement would deteriorate just because he's away from the project for a while Even if he completely vanishes for years, not looking at the code or following development discussions, when he reappears he'll know how out of touch he is, and act accordingly. dota imba legends v2.0.w3x You trusted his judgement before, so why not trust it always If high school diplomas do not expire, then commit access certainly shouldn’t. Sometimes a committer may ask to be removed, or to be explicitly marked as dormant in the list of committers (see the section called “Avoid Mystery”’ below for more about that list). In these cases, the project should accede to the person's wishes, of course. Avoid Mystery Although the discussions around adding any particular new dota imba legends v2.0.w3x committer must be confidential, the rules and procedures themselves need not be secret.